Thursday, 11 February 2016

Bibi Fatima's Persecution

Dr.Mazhar Naqvi

“There is no Sunni and Wahabi. All are Muslims only Shias are outside Islam. To understand it, we need to understand Prophet SAW and his companions. There was no Shia during Rasul SAW’s period hence, how Shias have come to exist now. The brain of Jews and Shias work alike. Jews are enemies of Nasranis and Shias are enemies of Rasul SAW and his momin Musalman Umar.”.

This is the English translation of a post sent in Hindi by a regular viewer. There is nothing new in it. For centuries, there has been difference between Imamis and non-Imamis over the position of Companions (Sahabas). Imamis say that the companions of the Holy Prophet are just like Sahabas of previous Prophets  among whom pious believers are to be respected, and no respect should be shown to  hypocrites. In contrast, other Muslim sects insist on not studying the history of the companions. Their plea is that they were sincere people and true believers, and believers should remain silent and turn a blind eye to their life story, for what Mortal Sins and heinous crimes they committed in their career have all been forgiven. Whereas Imamis are open to history and to studying renowned individuals with scientific impartiality to find truth, hardliners prohibit digging up the past and closing their minds with faith that propels them to respect all companions without looking into their merits and demerits.
The second Caliph Umar Ibn al-Khattab can be cited as an example in this context. Considered to be a great political leader and companion of Holy Prophet, Imamis accuse him of hatching a conspiracy to assassinate the Messenger of Allah. They also blame him for  his direct involvement in killing his only daughter  Bibi Fatima. However, scholars of majority of non-Imamis deny historical facts. They reject that  that the second Caliph carried out a brutal attack on  Lady Fatima  that  led to the miscarriage of her baby Mohsin. They deny even though many of their historical sources make specific mention of it. All three of Shahristani, Safadi and al-Natham report: "On the day of allegiance, Umar struck Fatima's stomach causing her to lose her baby! He shouted: “Burn the house no matter who is inside! There was in the house no other than Hassan, Hussain, Ali and Fatima. On that day, Second Caliph  attacked the House of Prophecy where  Ali Ibn Abi Talib  was engaged in worship and compilation of the Quran while Bibi Fatima  was behind the door of the house because she had tried to confront the attackers and remind them that what they were doing was unlawful. Nevertheless, second Caliph took advantage of the opportunity once the door had been set alight. He stormed the house and beat the Greatest Lady of All Worlds, whom the Prophet had praised time and again and given repeated warnings against doing her wrong.”
The leaders of the anti-Ahle-Bait sect sow seeds of doubt in the narration of  al-Natham, alleging that he had been influenced by Imami culture. The truth is that he was one of  staunchest opponents of Shias. His pupil Aljahidh says : "He was one of the fiercest people in condemning the Rafidis (Shiites) because of their vilification of the companions!....al-Natham believed that Abu Bakr was superior to Ali, and that the correct order of succession for the four was as follows: Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, Ali"!
The anti-Imami elements from the very beginning always sought to justify Caliph’s actions no matter how repugnant they were with various excuses. They defend him by  saying that such extremism was essential  to protect Islam and maintain unity between Muslims. Hence, al-Natham did not feel any shame in narrating the harsh treatment meted out  to Bibi Fatima. Similarly, Bukhari also derived pride in  mentioning in his Sahih  account of Second Caliph hitting Umme Farwa and other  women who wanted to mourn Hazrat Abu Bakr. al-Natham was also like Bukhari. He related the account of  attack on Bibi Fatima  without feeling any embarrassment nor he tried to cover up as he thought the action of second Caliph fully justified being an opponent of Imamis. Now, the anti-Imami scholars tried to cover the incident Because Bibi Fatima is not like any other woman. Attacking her is one of the biggest sins. Moreover, it is Kufr and abandonment of the religion of Islam.
(The blogger has no intention of showing any disrespect to Second Caliph or hurting sentiments of any sect. He has posted the article in response to the post of a fanatic who has also been hurling filthy abuses at the blogger even though he never criticized any companion. The blogger has given version of both the sects and narrated the persecution of Bibi Fatima on the basis of narration given by a staunch opponent of Shias. If anyone can refute, he can do so with liberty. His version will also be incorporated in the article that aims at only portraying the correct history and reveal truth. The blogger urge Muslims to research the issue and enlighten if they chance upon anything contradicting the contents.May Allah give right guidance to the writer as well readers?On request,more references of Non-Imami scholars can also be given.The blogger is a historian and writes without any prejudice or bias.)






Tuesday, 9 February 2016

Wahabism-A Gift of Britain

Dr.Mazhar Naqvi
Wahabism is actually not a school of theology. It is a political sect that originated from the attempts of British to dominate the Islamic world by dividing Muslims. This is evident from the book of a British secret agent Hempher who was instrumental in shaping Wahabism.In his book, he mentions that he went to Istanbul in 1710 AD, and stayed there for two years. Then he returned to London, got married and lived there for six months. Later he obtained a duty to Iraq and arrived in Basra. He met a young man named Muhammad ibn Abdul Wahab Najdi. He followed Najdi and lived in his house for two years.  They also designed a program to redefine Islam. To give fillip to his newly developed program, Najdi wrote “Kitab at-Tawhid” around 1736 AD. He explained that the polytheists only have two choices: (1) Embracing Islam, or (2) Embattled. This was in contrast to the maxim that the People of the Book have three options: (1) Embracing Islam, or (2) Pay Jizya (Protection Tax) and (3) Embattled.
With his explanation, Najdi legitimized sword, aggression, and slaughter. Then, the jihad began with the sword. Wahabi, under the leadership of Abdul Aziz stormed the city of Taif. They killed people on the street, in stores and in mosques. They attacked Karbala in 1802 AD and massacred and looted countless. They destroyed shrine of Imam Hussain and looted valuables. Wahabis did not spare the tomb of Hazrat Abbas. They also attacked Mecca and Medina. In Mecca, they prohibited pilgrims to enter into the city. In Medina, they attacked and insulted the Prophet’s Mosque and sold relics and jewelry kept at the holy tomb of the Prophet. The historian Alexei Vassiliev states “Having launched a terror to the Sunni population of  Hijaz, Ibn Saud occupied Mecca through the support of the British secret.” (A History of Saudi Arabia, p. 264)
Abdul Aziz bin Muhammad bin Saud in 1791 AD declared war against Amir of Mecca, Sharif Ghalib Effendi-official appointed by Ottoman Empire).
The fact that the Wahabi movement is formed and utilized by the United Kingdom (through the secret agent named Hempher) can not be denied. England is famous for creating sects often contrary to the beliefs of the majority, for the sake of running political “divide and conquer” (divide and conquer), as well as the Ahmadiyah group in India-Pakistan in the 19th century AD. Thus, by forming the Wahhabi movement , England pitted Arab Muslims with Turkey.Thus, the power of the Ottoman Empire can be torn down and occupied.
After fierce battles, Wahhabis seized Mecca in 1803 AD. In 1807 AD, they invaded Medina. The majority of the villages around Medina burned and destroyed. Its people were killed and looted. They forced people to accept the Wahabi beliefs.Then, the Turkish government ordered the governor of Egypt, Muhammad Ali Pasha, to punish Wahabi. He seized Mecca in 1812 AD. Wahabis fled to the mountains. After a long battle, Turks managed to beat them in 1818.

Wahabi bounced back with the help of British colonialism. When the British successfully invaded Bahrain in 1820 AD, Wahabi saw it as an opportunity to gain the protection of UK.In 1843 AD, Wahabi leader Faisal al-Saud managed to escape from his prison in Cairo and reached Najd. He  contacted the British and begged them to support his  representatives in Oman. In 1851 AD, he again pleaded for help.In1865 AD, the British sent Colonel Lewis Pelly to Riyadh to make a pact with the Wahabi. In 1866 AD, the Wahabi signed a friendship treaty with Britain. With the support of  British, as historian Ibn Hizlul reports “In 1924, the Wahabi forces entered the Taif, plundered it for three days. The scholars were dragged out from their homes and massacred. Hundreds of civilians were also killed. “(Tarikh al-Muluk Su’ud, hal.151-1533).There are other records also available to prove that the British shaped and supported Wahabis to break the power of the Ottoman Empire to create its puppet state i.e. Saudi Arabia. After emergence of America as the most powerful nation, Saudi Kingdom earned the friendship of Washington. Since then, they are dividing muslims through a network of preachers and madarsas in countries like India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Nigeria, Bangladesh and many others. In the process, their ideology has also become a threat to world peace. (The article is primarily based on a book titled Confession of a British Spy.Other references are also available on request).

Monday, 8 February 2016

Shia As Defined By Sunni Scholars.

Dr.Mazhar Naqvi

KYA SHIYA FITNA MUHAMMED SAW KI DAURE HAYAT ME WAJOOD ME AAYA YA NAHI ? (Did Shia Fitna exist during the life time of Prophet Hazrat Muhammad or not?.This question has been asked by my worst critic Mr. Hafeez once again. He has used word fitna instead of firqa out of his hatred against Shias. As he did not accept my submission that Shia means friend and follower, I am re-explaining the entire issue with the help of authentic references of eminent Sunni scholars.   
 The word “Shia” is derived from the Arabic word “Shaya’ah” meaning to ‘Love, Follow and Help’. Hafiz Abu Hatim Razi says  in his Az-Zainat that the first new word that came into general acceptance in Islam in the days of the Prophet was “Shia.” The word  applied to four prominent companions: Abu Dharr Ghaffari, Salman Farsi, Miqdad and Ammar Yasir. Another  Ahle Sunnah Ulema  Firozabadi in his Qamusu’l-Lughat says, “The name ‘Shia’ commonly means every person who is a friend of Ali and his Ahle Bait. The same meaning is given by Ibn Athir in Nihayatu’l-Lughat.
Commentaries of Ahle Sunnah describe the word Shia as “follower of Ali” and it was used during the time of the Prophet. In fact, it was the Prophet himself who introduced the word Shia as  “follower of Ali .” Holy Prophet about whom Allah says: “Nor does he speak out of desire. It is naught but revelation that is revealed.” (53:3-4)  called the followers of Ali “The Shia,” the “delivered,” and the “rescued.” Several books of Ahle Sunna such as Durre Manthoor in ‘Siyuti’, ‘Sawaiqa Mohariqa’ of Ibne Hajar Makki, ‘Hakeem II’, ‘Masnad’ of Imam Hanbal, ‘Tarikh Baghadid’ of Khateeb, ‘Rabiul Abrar’ of Zamakhshari, Ibne Atheer, Ibne Adi and other can be referred in this context.

Hafiz Abu Nu’aim Ispahani the pride of Ahle Sunnah has also related from Abdullah bin Abbas through his own chain of narrators in his book Hilyatu’l-Auliya  “When the following verse of the holy Qur’an was revealed: ‘(As for) those who believe and do good, surely they are the best of men. Their reward with their Lord is gardens of perpetuity beneath which rivers flow, abiding therein for ever. Allah is well pleased with them and they are well pleased with Him; that is for him who fears his Lord.’ (98:7-8), the Holy Prophet, addressing Ali, said: ‘O Ali, the best of creatures (Khairu’l-bariyya) in this holy verse refers to you and your followers (Shia). On the Day of Resurrection, you and your followers (Shia) shall attain such a position that Allah will be pleased with you, and you will be pleased with Him.’”

 Abu’l-Qasim Ali Bin Hasan (commonly known as Ibn Asakir Damishqi), who quotes Jabir Bin Abdullah Ansari, one of the greatest companions of the Prophet, as saying that he and others were sitting with the Holy Prophet when Ali Bin Abu Talib came in. The Holy Prophet said: “I swear by Him Who controls my life that this man (Ali) and his Shia shall secure deliverance on the Day of Resurrection.” In the Manaqib of Khawarizmi, the following is related from Jabir bin Abdullah Ansari: “I was in the presence of the Holy Prophet when Ali joined us, and thereupon the Holy Prophet said: ‘It is my brother that has come to you.’ Then, facing towards the Ka’ba, the Prophet took hold of Ali’s hand and said: ‘By Him Who controls my life, this Ali and his Shia will be delivered on the Day of Judgement.’
 In Chapter II of his Sawa’iq, Bin Hajar quotes Hafiz Jamalu’d-Din Muhammad Bin Yusuf Zarandi Madani as saying that the Holy Prophet said: “O Ali, you and your Shia are the best of created beings. You and your Shias will come on the Day of Judgement in such a condition that all of you will be pleased with Allah, and Allah will be pleased with you. Your enemies will be resentful, and their hands shall be tied round their necks.” Then Ali asked who was his enemy. The Holy Prophet replied, “One who is hostile to you, and who reviles you.”
Allama Samhudi, in Jawahiru’l-Iqdain, on the authority of Hafiz Jamalu’d-Din Zarandi Madani and Nuru’d-din Ali bin Muhammad bin Ahmad Maliki Makki, known as Ibn Sabbagh, who is regarded as distinguished scholars and eminent theologians of Ahle Sunnah  has also  stated the same thing. Mir Syed Ali Hamadani Shafi, another  Ahle Sunnah scholar, in his Mawaddatu’l-Qurba, and the well known anti-Shia scholar, Ibn Hajar, in his Sawa’iq-e Muhriqa narrate from Ummu’l-Mu’minin Umme Salma, the wife of the Prophet, that the Holy Prophet said: “O Ali, you and your Shias will abide in Paradise; you and your Shias will abide in Paradise.”
Many more traditions are available in support of the same point. Now it is for you to consider how it was possible that during the time of the Prophet four of his chief companions were called Shia. If the Prophet thought it was innovation, why didn’t he forbid the people to use it? The fact is that people had heard from the Prophet himself that the followers (Shias) of Ali were the inhabitants of Heaven. They were proud of it and openly called themselves Shias.(Though the article has been written in response to Mr. Hafeez’s question with proper referencing, the blogger is confident that he would reject everything on the ground that the scholars of Ahle Sunnah were misguided by Shias. When cornered, he rejects all references and resorts to abusing instead of reasoning. May Allah give him right guidance and decent manners)


Sunday, 7 February 2016

Defenders of Yazid ?Just Contemplate


Dr.Mazhar Naqvi

‘Syed Hafeez Hussaini’, May Allah forgive him for his follies, has turned bitterer. Earlier, he used to call me as Kafir but today he dubbed me as Dajjal. My only fault is opposition of Yazid. Mr. Hafeez considers him as legitimate Caliph and feels that scholars and historians spread poison against him at the instance of followers of Ahle-Bait. When I wondered how he could praise Yazid despite being a Syed and Hussaini, he replied that he was a Chishti but no longer believe in Sufi rituals as they are nothing but Dhakosla.(Drama).He also failed to furnish his Shijra(Family tree)and pleaded that he did not believe even in family genealogy. Finding him obsessed with issuing fatwa regarding anyone, I also asked him to issue fatwa about Holy Prophet and his progeny in view of the contradiction in his replies and his claim to possess extra-ordinary knowledge about religion. I used word fatwa instead of opinion because religious preachers derive great pleasure in issuing decrees in favor of anyone for a paltry sum and their greed is causing much harm to Islam. My query enraged him because did not want to respond. The reason was his acceptance about Imam Hussain as leader of Muslim and Yazid as legitimate Caliph. When asked how both the things could be possible, he called me Dajjal and kept mum when I wrote back to him the traits of Dajjal that matched with his replies to my queries.
 As the number Yazid’s supporters are growing thanks to Nasibi ideology, I am giving the following examples of Ibn Muawiya and leave the Muslim community to decide whether the support of Yazid is justified.  
Qazii Thana Ullah Panipati ,  a great scholar accepted by all Muslims, quoted about Yazid Quranic ayah 14:28 that states” Hast thou not seen those who gave the grace of Allah in exchange for thanklessness and led their people down to the Abode of Loss. Then in Tafsir he elaborated that  Bani Ummaiya had always rejoiced upon Kufr.However Abu Sufyan, Ameer Muawiya and Umaro bin Aas and others became Muslims. Later Yazid and his companions rejected the blessings of Allah and rose the flag of enmity towards Ahle Bait and finally brutally martyred Imam Hussain. Yazid even denied the Deen of Muhammad  After martyrdom of Imam , he said “had my predecessors lived they would have seen how I took revenge from the family of Prophet  and Bani Hashim, The couplet which Yazid composed ended with :” I will avenge Ahmed for whatever he did with my predecessors in Badr .He declared alcohol  permissible and said: If liquor is Haram in the Deen of Muhammad  then take it to be permissible according to the deen of Isa Ibn Maryam.(Ref.Tafsir al Mazhari Volume 5, Pages 211-212]
An idea about Yazid can also be formed about the comments of Ibn Kathir who writes in al Bidayah Volume 8 page 1169 "Traditions inform us that Yazeed loved worldly vices, would drink, listen to music, kept the company of boys with no facial hair [civil expression for paedophilia with boys, a form of homosexuality], played drums, kept dogs [civil expression for bestiality], making frogs, bears and monkeys fight. Every morning he used be intoxicated and use to bind monkey with the saddle of a horse and make the horse run".
The Proof of sending Lanat upon Yazid is derived from ayah mentioned by Al-Barzanji  in his Al-Ashaat and Imam Haythami in As-Sawaiq quoting Imam Ahmed .Once  his son Abdullah asked him about cursing  Yazid, and how sending Lanat upon him is mentioned in the book of Allah,. Imam Ahmed  mentioned these verses: “Would ye then, if ye were given the command, work corruption in the land and sever your ties of kinship? Such are the men whom Allah has cursed…(47:22-23), So could there be a greater fitna than the actions committed by Yazid? (Ref:Ruh ul Ma’ani by Imam Al-Alusi, Volume 9 Under Surah Muhammad 22-23].
In Tafseer Ruh al Maani, Alusi stated Yazeed the impure denied the Prophethood of Rasulullah . The treatment that he meted out to the people of Makka, Medina and the family of the Prophet proves that he was a kafir". Once in the gathering of Amir  Umar Bin Abdul Aziz  people talked about Yazid. Someone among the people called Yazid as Ameer Ul Momneen.   Umar replied in anger,'' you call Yazid  as Amir Ul Momneen and then gave order of 20 lashes to the person.(Ref.  Tahzeeb Al'Tahzeeb Vol 1 Page 361].People praising Yazid should thank Allah that they are not living during the regime of Umar bin Abdul Aziz or else they would have also been receiving lashes every day. However, they should refrain themselves from praising Yazid in view of his unholy character. Such action on their part will appease Allah and his Messenger. They should remember that Allah never likes a tyrant. Those who wish to see rejection of holy Quran by Yazid can also refer to the books namely 1. Al Bidayah wa al Nihayah Volume 8 page 204 Dhikr Ras al Husayn,2. Minhajj al Sunnah Volume 2 page 249 Dkikr Yazeed,3. Sharh Fiqh Akbar page 73 Dhikr Yazeed,4. Sharh Tafseer Mazhari Volume 5 page 21 Surah Ibrahim,5. Shazrah al Dhahab page 69 Dhikr Shahadth Husayn,6. Maqatahil Husayn Volume 2 page 58 Dhikr Shahdath Husayn,7. Tadhkira Khawwas page 148,8. Tareekh Tabari Volume 11 pages 21-23 Dhikr 284 Hijri,9. Tafseer Ruh al Ma'ani (commentary of Surah Muhammad)


Saturday, 6 February 2016

Shias Love Just Companions(Sahabas)

Dr.Mazhar Naqvi
At the outset, I offer my sincere apologies to all those Muslims who love Holy Prophet and his Ahle-Bait. My apologies come in the wake of my recent articles that were posted in reply to the accusations made by a fanatic. As he constantly accused me of having hatred against Sahaba Karam and glorified Yazid, I had no option but to highlight certain facts recorded by eminent scholars that indicate how Sahabas defied the instructions of Nabi Kareem. I know that a vast majority of Muslims hold all Sahabas in high esteem. They quote a Hadees of Imam Bukhari, declaring all those who saw the face of Holy Prophet as his companions. Contrary to the belief of majority, Imamis follow a stricter definition. They don’t consider every Muslim who saw the Prophet and lived in his lifetime as companions. Imamis are of the view that one who follows the precepts of Islam can only be considered as a companion. Whoever falls into this category is praised and whoever doesn’t is not treated as a companion.

Imamis argue that the Quran speaks negatively about many of those who professed Islam and lived with the Prophet. The Quran labels some as hypocrites, some  with low levels of faith and spirituality, some ready to turn back from their religion, some as  wrongdoers, and some  who claim that they are believers while faith has not entered their hearts. They give example of Malik bin Nuwayrah. He was a great companion of the Prophet and killed by a fellow Muslim who wanted to take his wife. Since both were companions, can both the murdered and the murderer be praised? Should such a murderer be considered worthy of praise just because he happened to see the face of the Prophet, Imamis opine.

The Shia belief is that a companion is just (acting in accordance to the precepts of Islam). If a person was not just and merely lived at the time of the Prophet he is not considered a companion in the sense that one should take him as a role model and praise him. Since Imamis apply a more strict formula for praising a companion, enemies of Islam use it as a tool to create sectarian strife and divide the community. They constantly accuse Imamis of having a hidden hatred for the companions of the Messenger of Allah. While condemning all Imamis who harbor hatred against noble Sahabas, I would like to assure the entire Muslim community that Imamis love the companions of the Prophet and consider them as role models.
No one can deny the fact that the companions supported the Prophet, defended him and sacrificed their entire existence for him. Allah praises the companions in the Quran stating: “Muhammad, the Apostle of Allah, and those who are with him are hard against the faithless and merciful amongst themselves. You see them bowing and prostrating, seeking Allah’s grace and pleasure. Their mark is [visible] on their faces, from the effect of prostration. Such is their description in the Torah and their description in the Evangel…Allah has promised those who have faith and do righteous deeds, forgiveness and a great reward.” (Quran, 48:29)
Imam Ali discussed the companions in these words “I have seen the companions of the Prophet but I do not find anyone resembling them. They began the day with dishevelled hair and dust on their faces and spent their nights in prostration and prayers. Sometimes they put down their foreheads and sometimes their cheeks [in prostration]…between their eyes there was thickened skin like the knees of goats…”
Imam Sajjad also prayed for the companions: “…and as for the Companions of Muhammad specifically, those who did well in companionship, who stood the good test in helping him, responded to him when he made them hear his messages’ argument, separated from  their mates and children in manifesting his word, fought against their fathers and sons in strengthening his prophecy, and through him gained victory; those who were wrapped in affection for him, hoping for a commerce that comes not to naught in love for him; those who were left by their clans when they clung to his handhold and denied by their kinsfolk when they rested in the shadow of his kinship; forget not, O God, what they abandoned for Thee and in Thee, and make them pleased with Thy good pleasure for the sake of the creatures they drove to Thee while they were with Thy Messenger”.
These descriptions exemplify that Imamis love and adore the companions of the Prophet. They praise and pray that Allah rewards them immensely for their efforts. So the Muslims should denounce those who make false allegations to spread hatred among various sects at the instance of Israel. Likewise, those who utter even a single word against any just Sahaba also deserves condemnation, for he too aims at division of Ummat-E-Muhammadi.(The article has been written in reply to false allegations made by a regular viewer Mr.Syed Hafeez Hussaini who pretends to be a Sunni but holds Yazid in high esteem).        


Thursday, 4 February 2016

Who martyred Imam Hussain?

Dr.Mazhar Naqvi

Syed Hafeez Hussaini has been viewing Muharram Mirror for quite sometime. Initially, he had no problem with the blog but he suddenly developed hatred against Shias after the execution of Sheikh Baqar Al Nimr. As his killing evoked widespread protests, Mr. Hafeez also became more vocal in his criticism of Iran and Shias. In the process, he started behaving like those Muslims who defend Yazid’s role in killing of Imam Hussain. Mr.Hafeez has repeatedly been claiming in his posts that Shias themselves killed Imam Hussain after inviting him to Kufa. His assertion is nothing but a lame excuse. His contention that Imam Hussain attained martyrdom due to treachery of Kufis only reminds how Yazid’ father Amir Muawiya had deflected the blame of Ammar bin Yasser’s killing. When Amir found himself cornered in the battle of Siffin because of killing of Ammar ,a fact prophesied by Prophet Muhammad, Muawiya simply passed on the blame to Ameer-Ul-Momneen on the plea that the latter brought him to Siffin and hence, responsible for the killing of Ammar- one of the greatest companions for whom Paradise was assured, But this rationale can’t be accepted or else Prophet will be held responsible for killing his own uncle Hazrat Hamza in the battle of Ohad, for it was Nabi Kareem who had instructed his uncle to be in the battlefield.(MA).Apparently, Mr. Hafeez ranks among those who shift the blame from the perpetrators of the crime to those who have nothing to do with it. Can anyone deny that the responsibility for killing Hamza lies with the infidels of Mecca who waged war against the Holy Prophet? Likewise, it is also a lame excuse that Imam Hussain was ditched by Shias of Kufa. In fact, he was not supported by companions and taabaeens who were aware of his exalted status and misdeeds of Yazid. Yet they preferred to remain silent even though it as in their knowledge that the Prophet  had often declared that Imam Husain as the Lamp of Guidance and the Ark of Salvation. That Imam and his brother Hasan were the Chiefs of the Youths of Paradise. And that both of them were his sons according to the Verse of Mubahelah in Surah Aale Imran (3): 61 when they along with the Prophet  and their parents Ali  and Fatima confronted the Christians of Najraan for malediction and drove them into submission. Pro-Yazidis claim that the companions stayed away from Karbala citing confusion between truth and falsehood and to avoid bloodshed. But they have no answer when asked why did not they remove their confusion by referring to holy Quran, stating ‘…so ask the People of the Reminder if you do not know.’ (Surah Nahl (16): Verse 43).It is a common fact that Sunni commentators of the Noble Quran have ranked Imam Husain among the People of the Reminder (Ahle Zikr).Further, even prophet had urged Muslims to support Imam Husain  as evident from the narration of his  companion Anas b. Haaris.” I heard Allah’s Prophet  say: ‘Verily my son, (Husain), will be killed in a land called Karbala; whoever amongst you is alive at that time must go and help him.’ Tarikh-o-Damishq vol 14 p 223
Those who defend Yazid can deny that Umar b. Saad b. Abi Waqqas, who led Yazid’s army was not among the leading taabaeen and the son of a leading companion or he had never heard of Imam Husain’s  virtues? Then why did he fight Imam Husain (a.s.)? Is it not treachery by the companions and taabaeen? These companions had resorted to treacheries in ample measure in Ohod and Hunain despite the Prophet’s  presence in their midst. Apart from dubious role of companions and Tabaeens, Yazid’s role is unmistakable. He is the one who sought to subjugate Imam Husain and wrote : ‘Force Husain, Abdullah b. Umar and Abdullah b. Zubair to give allegiance and don’t spare them”. Those who defend Yazid forget that a person is judged from his current inclination and not on the basis of his previous belief. Having disobeyed Allah, Iblis is no longer referred to as Allah’s worshipper although he was once an angel. Nor do common Muslims refer to companions  as infidels although they were the leading idol-worshippers  before the advent of Islam.

Likewise those who abandoned Imam Husain  in Kufa and joined Yazid’s ranks cannot be called as Shias. They  ranked alongside Yazid’s forces and all attributes used for Yazid’s forces applies to these so-called Shias also. Surprisingly, these pro-Yazidis  do not utter even a single word against  Talha and Zubair for  severing their allegiance and waging war against Hazrat Ali.(The blogger wants to make it clear that this article does not aim at hurting the sentiments of any  Muslim and has posted it solely because of the praise heaped on Yazid by a regular viewer.The blogger believes that no true Muslim would praise Yazid not because what he did with Imam Hussain but also for ransacking Medina and burning holy Kaaba.The blogger strongly believes in Muslim Unity and offers apology if anyone finds the contents of the article against his beliefs.)  

Muslim Unity-Why A Distant Dream?

Dr. Mazhar Naqvi
A regular viewer of Muharram Mirror is dead against Shia-Sunni unity. He considers all Shias as Kafirs and claims himself to be a Sunni. When his attention was drawn to the fact that Al-Azhar University has acknowledged Jafri school of thought as legitimate, he remarked “Shias managed to convince scholars of Jama-e- Azhar”. Likewise he rejects the books of all Sunni scholars on the ground that they were all misguided by Shias and hence not acceptable. Moreover, he praises Yazid and calls him as a true believer but maintains silence when asked about ransack of Medina and Mecca during his regime. The blogger deliberately did not take up the killing of imam Hussain ,for he had already described him as a Khariji who rebelled against a legitimate caliph.(Maaz Allah).His approach is simply ironical and rigidity is indicative of the fact how a whole generation is being prepared by hardliners to consider hatred against progeny of holy prophet as a part of their religion. As a result ,Unity among Muslims remain a distant dream.
The blogger would like to remind all Muslims that why can’t they be united when Europe can become  one union, states of America can emerge as ‘United States’ and East and West Germany can be united. Why are they busy in fighting with one another instead of paying attention on  poverty, sanctions, isolation, hatred against each-other, What pleasure Muslims derive by saying “ I declare you Kafir and I am the only Muslim, you have to believe what I believe in” Fanatics never try to think that where are Muslims heading. They are going astray as they have forgotten the basics of Islam. They no longer remember what the Lord has ordered in holy Quran“   “And  hold  firmly  to  the  rope  of Allah all  together  and  do  not  become  divided (3:103)”.
“As for those who divide their religion and break up into sects, you have no part of them in the least. Their affair is with Allah; He will in the end tell them the truth of all that they did.”(6:159).Fanatics also don’t remember the words of Rasul Allah wherein he said “ “O Allaah! Testify. Let those who are present inform those who are absent, because the person receiving the message might understand it better than the one who originally heard it. Do not become disbelievers after my death, and start killing each other” 
In defiance of Quranic injunctions and on the basis of fabricated and state sponsored fake sayings,some so called Muslims declare others Kafir and even wajib-ul-qatal (worth Killing).Situation has come to a stage that Muslims are being butchered .Likewise some so called scholars hurt feelings of other fellow Muslims by using foul language against their religious personalities. This practice is done by the illiterate speakers and paid agents for the purpose of creating fitna and Muslims should not fall prey to such fanatics. Before accepting the contents of any hate speech, they should question who is a Muslim? The answer is ”  someone who believes in One Allah and the Holy Prophet peace be upon him as His last messenger”So as far as some one beleives in the kalma, he can not be declared as kafir.Even  Salafi Scholar “Molana Ishaq” says “For sure not, otherwise the Holy Prophet would have ordered to kill all the non-muslims after Fatah-e-Makkah (victory of Makkah) but he did not do anything like that, instead he even had forgiven the murders of his own family members” So there must be no violence against any group, even kafirs,.Unfortunately some extremists  call shias as  Kafirs  whereas mainstream Sunni Scholars support unity.Ahmed – Deedat, teacher of Dr Zakir Naik, has stated “
” But we say to them no you are different you are Shia. This attitude is a sickness of the devil. He wants to divide us. Sunnis are 90% of the Muslim world and the ten percent who are Shias want to be partners and brothers with them in faith but the 90% are terrified? I cant understand why should you the 90% be so terrified. They should be the ones terrified. “ May Allah give right guidance to all. The blogger has posted this article as unity among Muslims is the need of the hour and there is also urgency to discourage fanatics who are out to kill all non-believers.    
-